Wild Horse Nine

W

I’ve had this idea for a novel for about 20 years: An aging character suffering from dementia asks his son to kill him. It seemed ripe with everything that makes good fiction hum: conflict, moral dilemma, tension, trauma, loyalty, fear, courage—take your pick.

Back in the day, I talked to my agent about it, and she said: Who wants to read about something like that, it’s too depressing, dementia is on the rise, we don’t want to be reminded, etc.

She told me instead to write something that everyone wants to read.

Thanks for the advice. I was surprised. She’d professed fandom about my ability to deftly handle serious moral crises within a story.

Her thoughts didn’t dissuade me. I wrote and failed, and wrote and failed, and could never get the concept to work. The relationship between the father and son wasn’t working, the tone was off, and I found it difficult to write about the inconsistent and progressively delusional state of a character with dementia.

I moved on. I wrote other books: The Culling. In Flight. The Suitor.

But I never let go of the concept, and last night I saw it play out on the screen. As any reader of this blog knows, the Delmar Dad Movie Club has long been disbanded, but Paul and I still make an occasional effort to get to the Spectrum for a flick.

Last night we saw “Wild Horse Nine.” The spine of the story tracks an aging CIA agent, Chris (John Malkovich), suffering from dementia and cancer, who asks his partner, Lee (Sam Rockwell), to kill him.

The concept didn’t work for me, but it did for writer/director Martin McDonagh.

Note: there may be a few spoilers here, but I don’t think they will spoil your experience if you see the film.

The story is set in 1973 in Santiago, Chile, just before the US-backed military coup against Salvador Allende, and then moves to Easter Island, where Chris wants to visit before he dies.

What the film does well is layer this CIA business on top of the underlying “please kill me” foundation, and in doing so mashes up genres, an increasingly popular storytelling approach these days. It’s a buddy movie, it’s a dark comedy, it’s a conspiracy plot.

A lot of the film’s strength and momentum comes from long, clever, dialog-heavy scenes between Chris and Lee about regret, fading memories, and Chris’s apparent involvement in the assassination of JFK. Lee is conflicted about what he’s promised to do, and their CIA boss, Steve Buscemi, wants to make sure the deed gets done because Chris is also spilling secrets. The excellent Parker Posey gets some screen time as Lee’s wife back home.

It’s well done, although not perfectly done. Some of the scenes drag on too long with talk, talk, talk, which got me shifting in my seat a bit. The mash-up of genres presents tricky tonal issues: sometimes the film feels sentimental when it should be serious, comedic when it would be better served cold. There’s a subplot with two young women that Chris and Lee meet in Santiago that feels like filler. The title is weak.

Overall, I recommend this film. The chemistry between Malkovich and Rockwell carries it; their acting is outstanding.

4/5 Stars.

By David Klein

David Klein

Published novelist, creative writer, journalist, avid reader, discriminating screen watcher.

Novels

Subscribe to this Blog

Enter your email address to receive notifications of new posts by email.

Get in touch